Compare
Cellared vs CellarMate
Both are iPhone wine apps with label scanning and drinking windows. CellarMate is built around capturing and recommending wines. Cellared is built around the cellar you already own and a published methodology for when to drink it. Here is how to choose.
Last updated 2026-06-25
What CellarMate does well
A wide capture and recognition toolkit
CellarMate leans hard into getting wines into the app. Alongside single-bottle label scanning it advertises bulk wine recognition from photos and receipt or invoice scanning to capture prices. If the friction you feel most is data entry, that breadth is genuinely useful.
Recommendations while you shop and dine
CellarMate extends past the cellar into the moment of buying: in-store shelf recommendations and a restaurant wine-list advisor. For a drinker whose wine life happens as much in shops and restaurants as at home, that is a real convenience.
A conversational sommelier as a primary surface
CellarMate puts a conversational sommelier assistant at the center of the experience, available across the app. If you like asking questions in natural language as your main way of working, that is a comfortable model.
Where Cellared is different
A published drinking-window methodology, not aggregated estimates
CellarMate describes its drinking windows as predictive, based on professional reviews and historical data. Cellared scores every bottle with the Cellared Ageability Index, a documented ten-factor model that weighs vintage, producer house style, oak, closure, and structure, and the methodology is published so you can see how a window is derived rather than taking a number on faith.
Food pairing drawn from the cellar you actually own
Cellared pairs food against the bottles in your cellar, so the answer to what to open with lamb tonight comes from wines you have, not a generic database. CellarMate does not advertise food pairing from your collection.
Built for migrating an existing collection
Cellared imports a CellarTracker CSV in about three minutes, preserving tasting notes, purchase data, and quantities, then recalculates a window for every bottle. A collector with years of records can move in without rebuilding. CellarMate does not advertise a CellarTracker import.
Private by default, no sharing feed
Cellared keeps your cellar, notes, and palate private, with no public profile to maintain. CellarMate includes a tasting journal oriented toward sharing experiences. If you want a quiet, private tracking tool, that difference matters.
A free tier with unlimited bottles
Cellared has a free tier with unlimited bottles and no credit card, so there is no trial clock and no cap to start. CellarMate does not publish pricing on its site.
Feature comparison
Side by side, by feature. CellarMate entries reflect what its site advertises; positioning changes, so treat this as a use-case guide.
| Feature | Cellared | CellarMate |
|---|---|---|
| Primary job | Manage and time the cellar you own | Capture, identify, and recommend wines |
| Drinking-window method | Published 10-factor model, per bottle (CAI) | Predictive, from professional reviews and historical data |
| Methodology published | Yes, at /methodology | Not published |
| Food pairing from your cellar | Built in | Not advertised |
| CellarTracker import | CSV import, about three minutes | Not advertised |
| Label scanning | Wine Lens, cellar-aware | Advertised, with bulk and receipt capture |
| Conversational sommelier | Reads your full cellar before answering | Yes, a primary surface |
| Privacy | Private by default, no feed | Tasting journal oriented to sharing |
| Free tier | Unlimited bottles, no card | Pricing not published |
| Platform | iPhone (iOS) | iPhone (iOS) |
The methodology behind Cellared's windows is documented in the Cellared Ageability Index, a ten-factor model. Moving from CellarTracker takes about three minutes through the CellarTracker import. For the wider field of cellar apps, see the guide to the best wine cellar apps.
When CellarMate is the better fit
- →Your biggest friction is data entry, and bulk photo recognition plus receipt scanning would clear it fastest.
- →You want recommendations while shopping or at a restaurant as much as you want cellar management at home.
- →A conversational sommelier assistant is how you most want to interact with a wine app.
- →You are comfortable without a published drinking-window methodology behind the timing advice.
When to choose Cellared
- →You are moving an existing collection over from CellarTracker and want a clean three-minute import.
- →You want to know when to open the bottles you already own, from a per-bottle methodology you can actually read.
- →You want food pairing drawn from your own cellar, not a generic catalog.
- →You want a private cellar with no sharing feed, and a free tier with unlimited bottles.
Frequently Asked
Can I use both Cellared and CellarMate?+
Yes. They emphasize different things. CellarMate is strong at capturing and identifying wines and recommending what to buy; Cellared is built around managing and timing the bottles you already own, with a published drinking-window methodology. Nothing stops you from trying both and keeping whichever matches how you actually use a wine app.
What is the main difference between Cellared and CellarMate?+
Both are iOS apps with label scanning and drinking windows, so the difference is what each is built around. CellarMate centers on capture, identification, and recommendation, including in-store and restaurant advice. Cellared centers on the cellar you own and when to drink it, scoring each bottle with the published Cellared Ageability Index and pairing food from your actual collection.
Do both apps scan wine labels?+
Yes. Both identify wines by reading the label with the camera rather than a barcode, which is the reliable method for wine. CellarMate also advertises bulk recognition from photos and receipt scanning for price capture. Cellared's label scan files each bottle into your cellar with a drinking window attached.
Does CellarMate offer food pairing from your own cellar?+
CellarMate does not advertise food pairing drawn from your own collection on its site. Cellared pairs food against the bottles you actually own, so a suggestion is something you can open tonight rather than a wine you would have to go buy.
Is CellarMate free?+
CellarMate does not publish pricing on its site, so check the current terms in the App Store before deciding. Cellared has a free tier with unlimited bottles and no credit card, with paid tiers for deeper features.
Which app has better drinking windows?+
They take different approaches, and the honest distinction is transparency rather than a head-to-head accuracy claim. CellarMate describes its windows as predictive, based on professional reviews and historical data. Cellared publishes the Cellared Ageability Index, a ten-factor per-bottle model, so you can read exactly how each window is calculated and decide whether the method earns your trust.
Try the cellar app
Free to start. Unlimited bottles. No card.
A drinking window on every bottle you own, from a methodology you can read.
Download on the App Store